Top 10 bagel shops in Brookhaven
Ranked by how complete and owner-verified the listing info is — hours, phone, website, services. No pay-to-play.
-
1Bagel Lovers Of Patchogue
499 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd #3, Brookhaven, NY 11772
Mon-Fri 5am-2pm, Sat-Sun 6am-2pm
-
2Jejojo Bagels Inc
207 Middle Country Rd, Brookhaven, NY 11720
Mon-Sun 5am-2pm
-
3Bagel Brothers
315 Main St Ste G, Brookhaven, NY 11741
-
4Bagel Lady Cafe
99 NY-25A #18, Brookhaven, NY 11786
Mon-Fri 5:30am-4pm, Sat-Sun 5:30am-3pm
-
5Bagelicious Cafe
1031 NY-112, Brookhaven, NY 11776
-
6Bagels Your Way Cafe
2799 NY-112 #8, Brookhaven, NY 11763
-
7Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe
379 NY-25A, Brookhaven, NY 11778
-
8Bagels Your Way
331 NY-25A #10, Brookhaven, NY 11766
-
9Pete's Bagels and Brunch
587 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11941
-
10Bagels & Such
90 Railroad Ave #107, Brookhaven, NY 11779
Of the 19 bagel shops listed in Brookhaven, 19 give a phone number, 3 publish opening hours and 14 have a website. No national chains here — every bagel shop on this page is independent. The nearest bigger selection is New York with 241.
All 9 other bagel shops in Brookhaven
Same order: the most complete listings first.
-
Best Bagels Around
700-9, Patchogue-Yaphank Rd, Brookhaven, NY 11763
-
Hilltop Bagel Cafe
623 Horseblock Road, Brookhaven, NY 11738
-
Miller Place Bagel & Deli
159 NY-25A #1, Brookhaven, NY 11764
-
Bagel Patch
705 Medford Ave Ste a, Brookhaven, NY 11772
-
Stacie's Bagels
414 Hawkins Ave, Brookhaven, NY 11779
-
Strathmore Bagel Of Mount Sinai
271 NY-25A, Brookhaven, NY 11766
-
Your Bagel Cafe
508 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY 11934
-
Bagels Your Way Cafe
Brookhaven, NY 11727
-
Joels Bagels
1699 Medford Ave, Brookhaven, NY 11763